Blog

Beyond the Legal Process: Redefining Permanency for Children and Families

For children and families involved in the child welfare system, permanency is often measured by a legal milestone: reunification, adoption, or guardianship. These outcomes represent significant steps toward stability, but they do not always tell the full story of what children and families need to thrive.

A court decision may establish a permanent home, but a child’s sense of belonging, identity, and connection develops through relationships and experiences that extend far beyond the legal process.

As we recognize National Adoption Month, the conversation about permanency must also consider what happens after a family achieves legal stability and how child welfare systems can better support families for the long term.

The National Kinship Review invited Tiffany Byrd, chief program officer of A Second Chance, Inc.’s (ASCI) Philadelphia Regional Office, and Dr. Tammy Hendrix, SWAN program administrator at Voce, to share their perspectives on the meaning of permanency, the importance of family connections and the policies and practices that help children and families build lasting stability.

As a SWAN affiliate, ASCI works within the statewide network to provide permanency services and support to children and families, bringing a direct service perspective to the broader conversation about achieving and sustaining permanency.

Permanency is More Than a Legal Outcome

At its core, permanency is about ensuring that children have safe, stable, and enduring relationships with people they can depend on throughout their lives.

“At ASCI, permanency means a child has a family they can count on for life, along with the emotional safety, belonging and connection that come with it,” Byrd explained.

While reunification, adoption, and guardianship provide important legal protections, Byrd emphasized that the completion of a legal process does not necessarily resolve a child’s questions about identity, family history, or belonging.

“A legal outcome is a milestone, not the finish line,” she said.

“A legal outcome is a milestone, not the finish line.”

Tiffany Byrd, ASCI’s chief program officer of the Philadelphia Regional Office

Hendrix shared a similar perspective, explaining that permanency, particularly from a child’s point of view, involves more than a legal designation. It means having a safe and caring home, maintaining relationships with loved ones and other important adults, and developing a sense of belonging, identity, and stability.

“For children involved with the child welfare system, permanency is not just about a legal label or a court decision,” Hendrix explained.

These perspectives highlight an important distinction between achieving legal permanency and experiencing lasting permanency.

For children who have experienced separation, loss, or instability, a permanent home is essential. Equally important are the relationships, connections, and support systems that help children feel secure and understand where they belong.

The Role of Kinship in Preserving Identity and Belonging

Family connections are central to a child’s understanding of who they are. For children involved in the child welfare system, maintaining those relationships can provide continuity during periods of significant change.

Kinship caregivers play a particularly important role in preserving these connections.

“Kinship caregivers are the bridge,” Byrd said.

When grandparents, aunts, uncles, older siblings, or close family friends step into caregiving roles, children may remain connected to familiar traditions, family histories, cultural practices, and communities.

These everyday connections, from family gatherings and shared recipes to stories passed between generations, help children maintain a sense of identity and belonging.

Kinship caregivers may also help preserve sibling relationships and maintain connections with birth parents and extended family members when it is safe and appropriate.

Hendrix emphasized that family relationships and cultural connections help shape children’s beliefs, values, and ability to navigate adversity. These connections can contribute to resilience and the development of coping skills that support long-term well-being.

“Family and culture provide the foundation for how all children see themselves, what they believe, and what they value,” Hendrix said.

“Family and culture provide the foundation for how all children see themselves, what they believe, and what they value.”

Dr. Tammy Hendrix, SWAN program administrator at Voce

Within SWAN, identifying and strengthening family relationships is an important component of permanency planning.

Hendrix noted that through diligent family searches, child preparation and child-specific recruitment services, child welfare professionals can identify relatives, kin and other significant adults who may serve as caregivers or provide meaningful support.

These efforts reinforce the importance of considering a child’s existing relationships when making decisions about their future.

Permanency is not simply about finding a place for a child to live. It is also about preserving the relationships that help make that place feel like home.

The Challenges That Continue After Permanency

Although achieving permanency represents an important milestone, families may continue to experience challenges long after a court case closes.

For many kinship caregivers, particularly grandparents who assume caregiving responsibilities unexpectedly, these challenges may include financial strain, housing concerns, health needs, and the demands of raising children later in life.

Children may also continue to navigate grief, trauma, or feelings of loss that emerge at different developmental stages.

Byrd noted that families may face complicated relationships with birth parents, strained extended-family dynamics, and difficulty finding services that understand the unique circumstances of kinship care.

“Some caregivers feel isolated because the people around them assume the hard part is over. It is not, and asking for help is a sign of strength,” she explained.

Hendrix emphasized that post-permanency instability is rarely the result of a single challenge. Rather, it can reflect a combination of factors involving the child, caregiver, and broader systems of support.

“Post-permanency instability is influenced by a combination of child, caregiver, and systemic factors rather than any single characteristic or experience,” Hendrix explained.

“As a result, it is recommended that families receive preparation for potential challenges, identify needs early, and maintain access to support as children develop and family circumstances change,” she added. 

Preventive check-ins, stronger caregiver preparation, improved information sharing, and timely access to intensive services can help families address concerns before they threaten stability.

Supporting Families Beyond Finalization

Sustaining permanency requires more than preparing families for a legal outcome. It also means ensuring they have access to resources, trusted relationships, and ongoing support as their needs evolve.

At ASCI, this work is rooted in a commitment to supporting the entire kinship triad: the child, the kinship caregiver, and the birth family.

“We walk alongside families from the first placement through permanency and after it,” Byrd explained.

ASCI’s work is also supported through its role as a SWAN affiliate, providing services that help children and families navigate the permanency process and access support beyond finalization.

SWAN brings together child welfare agencies, courts, legal professionals, permanency practitioners, families and community partners across Pennsylvania. The network provides program and legal technical assistance to the state’s 67 county child welfare agencies and supports collaboration among the professionals and organizations involved in permanency planning.

Through SWAN, affiliate agencies such as ASCI help deliver services including child preparation, family profiles, adoption finalization and post-permanency support.

Hendrix also highlighted SWAN’s role in funding post-permanency services for eligible families across Pennsylvania. These services support adoptive families, regardless of whether their children were adopted from foster care, as well as families who achieved permanency through permanent legal custodianship or formal kinship care following foster care.

Families can access three primary services:

  • Advocacy: Assessing family needs and connecting caregivers with appropriate services and resources.
  • Support groups: Providing opportunities for children and families to build connections, share experiences and receive support.
  • Respite: Offering temporary relief from daily caregiving responsibilities.

Together, these services help families navigate changing needs and maintain stability long after permanency is finalized.

Strengthening Permanency Through Policy and Practice

While individual services play an important role in supporting families, lasting permanency also requires child welfare systems to examine how policies and practices influence family stability.

Hendrix identified several opportunities to strengthen permanency outcomes in Pennsylvania, including increasing public awareness that kinship caregivers can pursue adoption or permanent legal custodianship and implementing kin-specific licensing.

She also emphasized the importance of systematically tracking instances when permanency arrangements do not remain intact, expanding access to adoption-competent mental health services, reducing barriers to modifying subsidy agreements, and addressing the stigma associated with seeking help.

These recommendations point to the need for policies that recognize the distinct experiences of kinship and adoptive families while providing more responsive support throughout their journeys.

For Byrd, strengthening permanency also requires professionals and communities to reconsider how they view kinship families.

Rather than seeing relatives and close family friends as alternative or secondary options, she encouraged child welfare professionals to recognize the strengths of existing family relationships and prioritize those connections whenever possible.

She also emphasized the role communities can play by offering practical assistance, patience, and respect to caregivers who have committed to raising children.

Together, these perspectives underscore the need for a more comprehensive approach to permanency, one that combines family-centered practice with policies and resources designed to sustain long-term stability.

A Commitment That Extends Beyond the Courtroom

National Adoption Month provides an opportunity to recognize the importance of adoption while also acknowledging the many pathways through which children experience permanency.

Regardless of how permanency is achieved, what matters most is ensuring children have safe, stable and supportive relationships that endure, along with meaningful connections to their families, cultures and communities.

The perspectives shared by Byrd and Hendrix remind us that achieving permanency is only one part of that commitment.

Sustaining permanency requires a shared commitment to preserving children’s connections to their families, cultures and communities. It also calls for responsive resources for caregivers and policies and practices that strengthen family relationships over time.

As Byrd reflected, “Children do not need perfect families. They need committed ones, with the support to stay together for the long haul.”


Newsletter Signup

Stay on top of ASCI news and events by signing up for our newsletter!

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)
Email(Required)
Caregivers, please check one.

The opinions expressed are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of A Second Chance, Inc.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *